I created this blog to share with you my concerns about healthcare system in Iran as an example of a developing country. I would like you to feedback on the major challenges of the healthcare system in Iran. Healthcare disparity, quality, and status of healthcare are among subjects I am very interested to write about. I hope this blog makes researchers and policymakers in the field more familiar with the healthcare system of this country.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Cesarian Section in Iran is 4 times world's standard
Source: Khabar Online, News Code: 57202
Accessed on Monday, April 26, 2010 at http://www.khabaronline.ir/news-57202.aspx
My comments: 1. To make this worse I would say that the majority of cesarian section operations are being performed under general anesthesia. Local (subdural) anesthesia that has a lower risk of complications is not the dominant mode of anesthesia in obstetrics in Iran 2. Based on a cross sectional study in Tehran , in private hospitals about 80% of all deliveries are done through cesarian section. Also, the results of this study show that the main reason to select cesarian section over normal vaginal delivery is pregnant mother's/ her husband's request for cesarian delivery.
Reference for the second tip: Garmaroudi G. et al. Cesarean section prevalence in Tehran, Iran. Annu Meet Int Soc Technol Assess Health Care Int Soc Technol Assess Health Care Meet. 2003; 19: abstract no. 16. Accessed on Monday, April 26, 2010 at http://gateway.nlm.nih.gov/MeetingAbstracts/ma?f=102275934.html
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
ISNA: 80 Percent of Patients in Iran Ask for Complementary Curing
"ISNA - Tehran
Service: Health
Tehran, Feb.19 (ISNA)-Experts' researches of Iranian Academic Center for Education, Culture and Research (ACECR) shows that 35 percent of patients affected by cancer use various methods of complementary curing.
"35 percent of patients affected by cancer use complementary curing methods that includes 81 percent supplication and 9 percent energy curing," said one of ACERC researchers.
According to the researches, 80 percent of patients ask physicians for complementary curing and 90 percent of them are satisfied by this method.
Among those who have used this method, 38 percent has used one curing method and 11 percent of them have used two methods of complementary method.
Complementary method consists of a collection of behaviors and believes that are used by patients for prevention and curing the disease and also betterment of health level.
End Item"
5 cancers get free treatment
My comment:
1.There has been a long debate in the country if cancers should be financially treated as long lasting disabling ill conditions such as chronic renal failure and thalssemia. The latter illnesses are called "bimari haye khas" which means 'exceptional diseases' and receive huge governmental subsidies. Patients with 'execeptional diseases" geneally utilize healthcare for these illnesses free of charge.
2. According to the literature stomach cancer ranks first among all type of cancers in Iran and I have no idea why this cancer is not included in the 'free treatment plan for cancers'.
Source: Gooya news quoted from ISNA news agency , http://news.gooya.com/technology/archives/084296.php, Feb 24, 2009
Saturday, February 24, 2007
Health in the news: Some facts on pharamaceutical usage in Iran
2-Total items of medicines sold in 2005 amounted to 16.5 billions (monetary equivalence: 11,526,602,000 Rials).
3-Average item prescribed per encounter was 3.5 in 2005 (3.6 in 1997).
4-Probable reasons for irrational drug utilization: Lack of systematized structure for pharmaceutical usage, absence of adequate control over drug utilization, unrealistic medical tariffs, inefficiency of medical insurers, adverse interests of pharmaceutical companies, and high financial benefits of drug distributors.
5-Mr. Davood Madadi, CEO of the Social Security Organization adds to the above list the tendency of people to visit doctors prescribing more than standard drug items.
6- Patients generally expect doctors to prescribe parenteral forms of medicines. They don't put believe in physicians who do not satisfy these expectations, a bitter fact of our health system.
7-Dr Mojdehi Azar stresses that low income of physicians in Iran encourage them to follow patients requests instead of concentrating on what the real needs of patients are.
8- Dr. Hassan Hovida, director of the General Physicians Association in Iran, says that patients are the main inducers of over-prescription of medicines in Iran.
[Extracted from a report by Ali Akhavan Behbahani]
Source: Jamejamonline, www.jamejamonline.ir, Feb 21, 2007
Code: 27N
Friday, February 16, 2007
Possible rise of out-of-pocket health expenditures in 2007-8
Sources:
1-http://pezeshkan.ir/ .Feb 3, 2007 (original reference: Mehr News interview with Dr. Bijan Shahbazkhani, and Dr. Jahanbakhsh Aminia , members of the Health Commission of the Parliament)
2-http://pezeshkan.ir .Feb 4, 2007 (original reference: Mehr News interview with Dr. Ahmad Reza Jamshidi, the Vice Chairman of the I.R.Iran's Medical Council)
3-http://pezeshkan.ir . Feb 3, 2007 (original reference: Fars News interview with Dr. Mohammad Hossein Tarighat, the Vice Chaiman of the Welfare Ministry)
Code:5A
Sunday, February 11, 2007
Health in the news: Last updates on the number of medical human resources in Iran
70,000 General Practitioners(completed 7-year medical school)
25,000 Medical Specialists and Subspecialists
20,000 Dentists (General and specialist)
13,000 pharmacists
3500 Laboratory Medicine Specialists (either 7-8 year and 10-11 year educational programs)
40,000 Midwifes (all has a formal 4-year university education).
Total: 170,000
My comment: This total does not include nurses and theyare I guess all members of the IMC and should be counted in.
Source: http://aftabnews.ir/vdciw3at1wa35.html , http://www.aftabnews.ir/ August 13, 2006
Code:26N
Health in the news: establishing provincial hemophilia clinics
Source: www.aftab-yazd.com , No: 2002, Feb, 6 2007
Code: 25N
Health in the news: 75,000 new annual cancer cases in Iran
Source: www.aftabeyazd.com , No: 2005, Feb, 10 2007
Code: 24N
Health in the news: If approved, people won't pay for expensive medicines
Source: www.jamejamonline.ir , Feb, 7 2007
Code: 23N
Saturday, January 27, 2007
Health in the news: 18 million illegal use of the SSIO's health insurance plan in one year
Source: www.baztab.ir, Aug 31,2006
Code:22N
Health in the news: It's not true to say the poor pay 10 times more than the better-off for health!
Source: www. aftabyazd.com, Jan 7, 2007 ; No: 1980
My Comment: I agree with Mr. Shahriari that this number (10 times) cannot be true (You can find the estimated values from the National Statistical Center) but I believe that in general the poor receive services of lower qualities. Residents of hard to reach areas, those who reside in ghettos, and pensioners have a poor access to quality healthcare.
Code: 21N
Health in the news: Possible negative growth rate for per capita public health expenditure
According to the fourth National Development Plan (2005-2009) per capita health expenditure share of the government was determined to be 7000 Toman (approximately 7.5 USD) while the real allocated share of the government for the coming year is 3660 Toman (3.2 USD) for residents of urban areas and 1660 Toman (1.2 USD) for the rural dwellers he added.
Mr Baghbanian says that residents of rural areas cannot use their health plans to utilize urban health facilities.
Source: www.aftabyazd. com, Jan 25, 2007 No:1995
Code: 20N
Wednesday, January 24, 2007
Six principles of Iranian Health System
"1)priority of preventive care as a long-term asset, 2) priority of rural and underprivileged areas, with special attention to high-risk groups,3) priority of general practice over specialized medical care, 4) priority of outpatient over inpatient care, 5) maximum feasible integration of preventive and curative services,6) and decentralization, aimed at forming self-sufficient regional and local facilities."
Source: Shadpour K. Primary healthcare networks in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal.2000;6(4):822-825
My comment: I think the Ministry of Health has gone to a great length to make these happen but what we see now after almost 3 decades are somewhat different from the principles. I can see that the government has great achievements in fulfilling the first, the second , and the fifth principles but could not pave the way for the sixth principle. Iranian PHC system is a unique one and has contributed a lot in rapid decline of child and maternal mortality in spite of progressive drop of the economy for many years after the revolution. However, the system failed in decentralization of the services. The fourth principle remained untackled until the introduction of a national program to set up a family medicine network in recent years. I don't know what to say about the fourth principle but to me is not as important as the others. I know that the outpatient care consumes the most part of people's out-of-pocket payments for healthcare and more than 90% of the outpatient care is in private sector. I don't know for sure how the fourth principle facilitated the emergence of the poorly supervised outpatient care market.
Code: 4A
Sunday, January 21, 2007
Health in the news: Establishment of electronic registry network of health insurance plans cuts the costs by 30%
Source: www.pezeshkan.ir, Jan 8,2007
My comment: I did not understand what kind of expenses might be cut following this intervention. E-registry sounds like an effective intervention though. In Iran less than one percent of the health insurances are private. So, the government has a good opportunity to put all the public information on health insurance plans together and make one huge data base. Over-insurance is a real problem. I used to see many people presenting more than one or even more than one insurance plans to doctors at the time of visit. Seems to me people tend to keep more than one insurance plans just to receive a better protection. Notwithstanding double and triple insurance , people are not protected by either of their plans in some occasions.
Code:19N
Saturday, January 20, 2007
Health in the news: With 120 billion dollars annual income Iran should not be viewed as a poor coutnry
Source: www.aftabyazd.com, Jan 17,2007 No:1988
My comment: In addition to insurance coverage one would think of the efficiency of the health insurance plans. Healthcare Utilization Survey 2003 showed a 75% self reported health insurance coverage in the country which differs from the official reports.
Code: 18N
Health in the news: Iran needs 500 more medical diagnostic laboratories
Source: http://pezeshkan.ir , Jan 19 , 2007
Code: 17N
Health in the news: Some facts on Road Traffic Accidents in Iran
1-Annual number of road traffic victims is 330,000.
2-Each year, 30,000 death are registered due to RTI.
3-Most accidents take place within 30 kilometers of urban areas.
4-Total length of roads is 180,000 kilometers from which only 31,000 km is either highway or main road(rahe asli in Persian). The remainder are 44,000 km of hazardous side roads (rahe far'ee in Persian) and 100,000 km rural roads.
5-Unexpectedly, the police patrol only 23,000 km(13%) of the entire roads.
6- 90% of travels travel through the ground while rail and air travels comprise 7% and 3% of the grand total respectively.
7-14 million out of 65 million daily travels happen in the capital (Tehran).
8- In Tehran 45% of travelers use public transportation. The remnant use their own private vehicle.
9- With a growth rate of 17%, two million four-wheeler vehicles and motor bikes per year (one million each) are being produced in the country while the growth rate for the road network is only 2%.
10-The government needs 1000 billion Toman (more than a billion dollar) to fix 1500 unsafe points already made known by the experts.
11-20 billion Toman per day (more than 20 million dollars) are spent on RTI.
12-70% of RTI deaths in the country are attributed to violation of the rules by drivers.
13-Nearly all the cars have not equipped with airbag or ABS (Anti-lock Braking System) which are reported as a safe measure to prevent fatal events in RTIs.
Source: www.baztab.ir , Jan 18, 2007, Code: 58295
My comment: I have no insight into the cost of RTI. It sometimes happens that an inadvertently placed extra zero in the reported numbers makes a huge difference. You need to use caution when you want to cite the above mentioned numbers. They may give us a sense of what the problems are but in my opinion the numbers need to be checked over. For example I am not certain about the extent to which the roads are patrolled by the police.
Code:16N
Monday, January 15, 2007
Health in the news: Per capita insurance premium for diabetics
Source: www.jamejamonline.ir, Jan 12 , 2007
Code: 15N
Sunday, January 14, 2007
Health in the news: Total Health Expenditure as a percent of GDP in Iran is less than that of comparable countries
Source: http://www.aftabyazd.com/ , Jan 13, 2007 No: 1984
Code:14N
Health in the news: Third wave of HIV infection is on the way
Source: www.jamejamonline.ir , Jan, 10 2007
Code: 13N
Health in the news: Updates on HIV/AIDS in Iran
The latest HIV/AIDS statistics (December 20, 2006) show:
1- HIV positive or AIDS: 14,090 diagnosed cases (13,308 (94.4%) male and 782(5.6%) female).
2-From the total mentioned above, 789 male and 75 female have diagnosed as AIDS.
3-4407 of them are in the age range of 25-34 years (most frequent affected age group) followed by the age group of 35-44 years with 3338 cases. Among cases with AIDS: 25-34 years:298 cases, and 35-44: 296 AIDS patients.
4-Most frequent route of the infection transmission was IV drug abusing (64.9%) followed by unknown (25.5%), Sexual (7.5%), blood and blood products transfusion(1.7%) and finally vertical (maternal) transmission(0.5%). Among those died of AIDS: IV drug abusing (72.1%), unknown (10.5%),sexual(9.1%),blood and blood products transfusion(7.1%), and vertical transmission(0.6%).
5-Mortality: 1760 deaths (96.3 % male) up to the date of this report.
Source: http://pezeshkan.ir, Jan 6 2007
My comment: According to different sources some 2 (an official report) to 6 (WHO estimates) million individuals in Iran are opium addict. A considerable majority of the addicts are IV drug abusers. If drug addiction continues to be this high, IV drug abusing will remain the main route of HIV transmission in Iran. It seems that the contribution of sexual contacts (mostly heterosexual) as a route of HIV transmission in the total number of HIV positives will considerably rise in near future.
Code:12N
Wednesday, January 10, 2007
Health in the news: physician per population
Source: Jamejamonline, Jan 6, 2007
Code:11N
Health in the news: Lack of hospitals in some districts of the coutnry
Source: Jamejanonline, www.jamejamonline.ir January 10, 2007
Code: 10N
Sunday, January 7, 2007
Private sector and advanced diagnostic healthcare
Now, the Ministry of Health has realized that inequality in healthcare utilization is going to be the most important challenge of Iranian healthcare.The MOH does not have effective means to take control over the expanding private sector and people have to pay most of the healthcare out of their pocket.
Code:4A
Health in the news: Therapeutic care for road traffic injuries is completely for free
Source: Baztab,Jan 3, 2006, http://www.baztab.com/ news code: 56945
My comment: I don't know for sure what percent of RTI victims are being transferred to private hospitals but I suspect the majority of cases receive their advanced therapeutic care in public hospitals. Private hospitals are not willing to accept multiple trauma cases; hence, they have not expanded their capacity to admit these patients. All ,for example, know that Sina and Shohadaye Tajrish Hospitals are two hospitals in Tehran with advanced trauma care and their emergency trauma services providing free of charge services for RTI cases happening anywhere in the country.
Code:9N
Health in the news: Iranian physicians achieved the best possible survival rate for their patients with liver transplant
Source: http://pezeshkan.ir/, December 29, 2007
My comment: There is no doubt that the rate of successful liver transplantation is increasing in the country. However, comparing with kidney transplantation, this rate seems to be very small. The first liver transplantation surgery in Iran back to more than 20 years ago but it was limited to Shiraz Namazi Hospital for quite a lot of years. Recently, the country has expanded the capacity for liver transplantation surgery in Tehran and maybe some other big cities but I guess Iran has not enough expert liver transplant surgeons and hepatologists in order to increase this capacity in short term.
Code:8N
Health in the news: Health insurance organizations are not able to cover all health needs of the population
Source: No: 1977, Jan 3, 2007 Aftab newspaper, http://www.aftabyazd.com/
My comment: I think this is quite understandable. We have at least 4 huge health insurance companies in Iran:Social Security Organization, Medical Treatment Insurance Organization, Imdad (relief) Committee Health Insurance for poor people, and Military Service Health Organization. Private insurance's coverage is around 1% . Many have double and even triple coverage while some (approximately 25% according to 2002 Household Healthcare Utilization Survey ) lack any. People who are working with a number of prestigious public, or private organizations benefit from a special coverage provided by complementary health insurance policy. Many attempts have failed so far in order to integrate the plans and build up a unified one. This remains, I believe, to be a major problem until the system makes an effective and simple policy to have one integrated health insurance plan for the entire population or alternatively implement a HMO-type policy.
Code:7N
Monday, January 1, 2007
Health in the news: Emergency service covers only 9% of road traffic accidents in Iran
Source: Jamejanonline, December 31, 2006
Code:6N
Saturday, December 30, 2006
Road traffic injuries in Iran, a fast look on a disappointing report
In 2003, RTI death rate in Iran was estimated to be 34.2 in 100,000 population while the world average was 28.8. RTI death seems to be higher in provinces with high travelling rate but low ratio of highway roads to non-highway roads. In some provinces RTI death in rual areas were higher than that of urban areas. RTI Death rate was consistently 3-5 times more in men than in women. 46.8% of RTI deaths happend on streets inside villages and cities. Rural roads oustside villages was the place of 19.5% of RTI deaths while 21.5% of death happened on intercity roads. Only 8.5% of RTI deaths took place on highways (inside or outside the cities). Motorcyclists constituted 51.7 % of RTI deaths. Pedestrains, four-wheeler occupants, and occupants of vehicles with more than four wheels comprised 17.5%, 14.9% and 11.3% of total RTI deaths. 49.1% of all RTI deaths happened immidiately after accident and on the accident scene, while 13.9% and 28.3% of them happened during transferring to hospitals and after hosptalization respectively. 95% of RTI deaths happened within 2 hours after accidents. Only 14% of RTI victims were transferred to hospitals by ambulance and just 40% of RTI victims were transferred to hospitals within 20 minutes after accident. In 2001, Iranian experts guesstimated that RTI causes 600 million US dollars loss in one year.
Source: Naghavi M, Ja'fari N, Alaeddini F, Akbari ME, Epidemiology of external causes of injuries in I.R. Iran. 2004, Ministry of Health and Medical Education, Tehran-Iran
My comment: I think the numbers in the report are self-expressing. Only 12 provinces were included in this study and all major provinces plus Tehran and its suburbs were excluded. If added, Tehran in itself with 13 million population and millions of motorcyclist can make major changes to the presented rates and propotions .
Code:3A
Thursday, December 28, 2006
Health in the news: 50,000 annual mortality due to congestive heart failure in Iran
Source: www.pezeshkan.ir, December,28 2006
My comment: It shows that the health transition (from infectious disease to western disease pattern plus population aging) has already happend. You can find tabulate data on burden of disease in Iran from the book published by the Ministry of Health titled "Simaye Marg dar 18 Ostan) by Dr. Naghavi and his colleagues.
Code:5N